Elecraft P3 vs LP-PAN2 - Sat, Apr 12, 2014
So I recently have purchased an Elecraft P3 panadapter to go with my K3. Since I bought an LP-PAN sometime last year, I should probably compare them both so people on the fence can decide which one to get.
Initially after adding the IF-Out board on the K3, I wanted to add some sort of panadapter. I mean who doesn’t have one now days. Since I had built a few Softrock SDR’s, I already had the equipment (ie: professional-grade USB sound card) needed to decode the I/Q signals into something my computer could understand. So getting the LP-PAN2 was a no-brainer. Just plugged it in, cranked up NaP3 and off I went.
Then I really saw the power of a panadapter. I wanted something that I could go portable with (like deer hunting) or to Field Day and not lug my shack desktop around. Enter the P3 (I got the SVGA card as well).
- Plug and Play with K3 with regard to CAT control and frequency sensing.
- No external sound card needed.
- No ground loops or driver issues with Windows.
- Powered by 12v jack on back of K3 (<—HUGE PLUS). This means that its 100% self contained and doesn’t require any external connections short of what it plugs into the K3 for power, CAT and IF-out.
- Typical awesome Elecraft support.
- – Screen is small, but SVGA card (few hundred bucks more) fixes that issue
- – Visually functional (I like it, but I also like the command prompt) but not very eye-candyish.
- – Cant QSY with the mouse clicking on the frequency you want.
- – Expensive
- Lets you run whatever panadapter software you wish
- Can plug into the 12v plug on the back of the K3
- Cheaper than the P3
- – Requires a highish-end soundcard to be really functional
- – Requires a pretty powerful computer if you want to do other things on your computer and have the panadapter running.
- – Although the box itself is very portable, the computer and other accessories needed to make the box useful isn’t.
If I was just starting out and didn’t have the Softrock experience before (meaning I didn’t have the sound card and cables laying around) I would have probably ordered the P3/SVGA right off the bat. However since a good chunk of the panadapter project involved existing equipment that was already paid-for, I opted to go the LP-PAN route just to see how much use it would be. Am I selling the LP-PAN? No. There are times where I want to use NaP3 or some other software that the P3 cant run (like CW Skimmer). Fortunately, the P3 has an IF splitter which allows me to daisy-chain the LP-PAN on the back of the P3 and run both at the same time (although it does have a 3db signal hit for splitting the signal).
Now Elecraft has the PX3 which is the P3 in a tiny case that uses the I/Q outputs on the KX3. Cant wait!